User talk:Zenlima
Hi, I use this page to support my question regarding context and summarize the result. Once a problem is solved I will move that text into the "normal" wiki pages.
Contents
Bug: Formula numbering - subnumbers and list of formulas
All following example have following frame:
\usemodule[newmath] \setupformulas[way=bytext,prefix=no] \setupsubformulas[conversion=romannumerals] \starttext ...(example placed here)... \stoptext
What works
formula
Expected formular number: (1)
\placenamedformula[one]{Der einfache Test} \startformula c^2 = a^2 + b^2. \stopformula
Result: (1) -> Works
align - formular [+]
Expected formular numbers: (1) and (2)
\placeformula \startformula \startalign[n=3, align={right,middle,left}] \NC PM \xrightarrow \NC R_{PM} \NC \xrightarrow PM \NR[+] \NC R_{PM} \NC = \NC \{ A, B, C, D, E\} \NR[+] \stopalign \stopformula
Result: (1) and (2) -> Works
align - subformular [+]
Expected numbers: (1.a), (1.b), (1.c), (1.d) and reference on (1) and (1.b)
\startsubformulas[eq:ax=b] \placeformula \startformula \startalign \NC a \NC \eq b \NR[+] \NC c \NC \neq d \NR \NC \NC \neq f \NR[eq:sub] \NC \NC \geq g \NR[+] \NC \NC \leq h \NR[+] \NC \NC \eq i \NR \stopalign \stopformula \stopsubformulas
Result: (1.a), (1.b), (1.c), (1.d) -> Works.
BUT: Every formula with a reference is automatic listed in the table of formulas (nameless) - at the moment there is no possiblity to have a reference without listing the formula.
eqalignno - formula
Taken from wiki and removed the subformulanumber. Expected formular numbers: (1), (2), (3) and (4):
\placeformula \startformula \eqalignno{ c^2 &= a^2 + b^2 &\formulanumber \cr c &= \left(a^2 + b^2\right)^{\vfrac{1}{2}} &\formulanumber\cr a^2 + b^2 &= c^2 &\formulanumber \cr d^2 &= e^2 &\formulanumber \cr} \stopformula
Result: (1), (2), (3) and (4) -> Works
What does not work
List of formulas
\placelist[formula][criterium=all,alternative=c]
The list of formulas seems to be totally out of order. Strange numbering and missing names. Needs more investigation once some of the named formulas constructions are fixed.
subformula
Expected formular numbers: (1a) and (1b)
\startsubformulas[eq:1] \placeformula[eq:first] \startformula PM \xrightarrow R_{PM} \xrightarrow PM \stopformula \placeformula[eq:second] \startformula R_{PM} = \{ K, F, Z, U, I, J\} \stopformula \stopsubformulas
Result: (1a) and nothing -> Does not work.
align - formula (subformulas->formulas->formula)
Expected formular numbers: (1a) and (1a) and a reference to formular (1b)
\startsubformulas \startformulas \placeformula \startformula \startalign[n=3, align={right,middle,left}] \NC PM \xrightarrow \NC R_{PM} \NC \xrightarrow PM \NR[+] \NC R_{PM} \NC = \NC \{ A, B, C, D, E\} \NR[a] \stopalign \stopformula \stopformulas \stopsubformulas
Result: nothing and nothing -> Does not work.
align - subformula
Expected formular numbers: (1.1), (1.2) and (1.c) plus reference on (1.1) and (1.2)
\placesubformula \startformula \startalign[n=3, align={right,middle,left}] \NC PM \xrightarrow \NC R_{PM} \NC \xrightarrow PM \NR[gleichung1a][.1] \NC R_{PM} \NC = \NC \{ A, B, C, D, E\} \NR[gleichung1b][.2] \NC R_{PM} \NC = \NC \{ A, B, C, D, E\} \NR[+][c] \stopalign \stopformula
Result: (1), (2) and (3) -> Does not work.
Expected formular numbers: (1a) and (1b) plus reference on (1a) and (1b)
\placesubformula \startformula \startalign[n=3, align={right,middle,left}] \NC PM \xrightarrow \NC R_{PM} \NC \xrightarrow PM \NR[gleichung1a][+] \NC R_{PM} \NC = \NC \{ A, B, C, D, E\} \NR[gleichung1b][] \stopalign \stopformula
Result: (1) and (2) -> Does not work.
eqalignno - subformula
Directly taken form wiki. Expected formular numbers (1), (1a), (1b) and (2):
\placeformula \startformula \eqalignno{ c^2 &= a^2 + b^2 &\formulanumber{a} \cr c &= \left(a^2 + b^2\right)^{\vfrac{1}{2}} &\subformulanumber{b}\cr a^2 + b^2 &= c^2 &\subformulanumber{c} \cr d^2 &= e^2 &\formulanumber\cr} \stopformula
Result: Does not compile Does as the command type{subformularnumber} is unknown -> Does not work.
Suggestion for new syntax
In progress...
The needs out of existing syntax and my personal experience:
- formulas and subformulas in the same block
- referencing on a subformula does not include automaticly a entry in the list of formulas
- simple, block and eqalignno
Simple
Expected formular number: (1) and list entry (1) -> "Der einfache Test"
\placeformula[reference={one},listlabel={Der einfache Test}] \startformula c^2 = a^2 + b^2. \stopformula
Expected formular number: (1) and list entry (1) -> "Der einfache Test"
\placeformula[reference={one},listlabel={Der einfache Test}] \startformula c^2 = a^2 + b^2. \stopformula
Expected formular number: (1.3) and list entry (1.3) -> "Der einfache Test"
\placeformula[sublevel={.3},reference={one},listlabel={Der einfache Test}] \startformula c^2 = a^2 + b^2. \stopformula
Block notation: NR
No specific values -> [+] otherwise classic attribute/value [...]
Expected numbers: (1.a), nothing, (1.b), (2), (2.a), nothing and (3); with reference on (1) and (1.b); with list entries of (1) -> "System of stuff", (2.a) -> "Great piece" and (3) -> "Last part"
\placenamedformula[reference={eq:ax=b},listlabel={System of stuff}] \startformula \startalign \NC a \NC \eq b \NR[sublevel={.a}] \NC c \NC \neq d \NR \NC \NC \neq f \NR[reference={eq:sub},sublevel={.b}] \NC \NC \geq g \NR[+] \NC \NC \leq h \NR[listlabel={Great piece},sublevel={.a}] \NC \NC \eq i \NR \NC \NC \eq i \NR[listlabel={Last part}] \stopalign \stopformula \stopsubformulas
eqalignno
Expected formular numbers (1), (1a), (1.c) and (2); reference on (2); list entries (1.c) -> "Yea!" and (2) -> "Ups"
\placeformula \startformula \eqalignno{ c^2 &= a^2 + b^2 &\formulanumber \cr c &= \left(a^2 + b^2\right)^{\vfrac{1}{2}} &\formulanumber[sublevel={a}]\cr a^2 + b^2 &= c^2 &\formulanumber[sublevel={.c},listlabel={Yea!}] \cr d^2 &= e^2 &\formulanumber[listlabel={Ups},reference={eq:ups}]\cr} \stopformula